Read
The book that names the idea, and the library it stands on — every study and book behind the argument, annotated, including the ones that cut against us. Check our homework.
The annotated library
The library the argument rests on.
Grouped the way the argument moves. Entries marked against us are the strongest material for the other side — read those first if you're skeptical.
The yardstick problem — status survives abundance
The single most important book behind step one of our argument. Positional goods — scarcity that is social, not physical — are why growth alone never ends the race for standing.
Is the Desire for Status a Fundamental Human Motive?
The review that concludes status-seeking is fundamental — across cultures, genders, ages. The reason we design a better yardstick instead of pretending we can have none.
The Theory of the Leisure Class
"Conspicuous consumption," coined before the modern consumer existed to prove it. Satirical, pre-empirical, and still the sharpest description of money as display.
Money, happiness, meaning
Income and emotional well-being: A conflict resolved
The adversarial collaboration that killed the "$75k plateau" meme: happiness rises with log income for most people, flattening above ~$100k only for the unhappiest fifth. We cite this instead of the meme, on purpose.
Long-Run Effects of Lottery Wealth on Psychological Well-Being against us
Swedish lottery winners stay more satisfied with life up to two decades after winning. The cleanest evidence that money causally helps — anyone arguing "money doesn't matter" has to get past this, which is why we never argue that.
Rising morbidity and mortality in midlife among white non-Hispanic Americans
The "deaths of despair" finding: suicide, overdose, alcoholic liver disease rising among those the economy stopped needing. Their interpretation — lost work, community, and meaning, not income alone — is contested, and they make it carefully.
Purpose in Life and Its Relationship to All-Cause Mortality and Cardiovascular Events
Meta-analysis, 136,265 people: purpose predicts ~17% lower mortality after adjustment for confounders. Observational, adjusted — never experimentally isolated.
The best-validated account of what well-being is made of: autonomy, competence, relatedness. Note what isn't on the list.
Why Are the Unemployed So Unhappy?
Losing work hurts far more than the lost paycheck explains — the classic panel evidence that work carries identity and purpose, not just income.
Where "anomie" comes from — and the observation that suicide rose in booms too. Prosperity outrunning meaning is a nineteenth-century finding.
Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren
The founding text of the post-scarcity question: what is worth doing when nothing is required of you? His growth math was roughly right; his 15-hour week never came — and the reasons why are half of what this site is about.
The paradox literature — when rewards corrupt, and when they don't
The Gift Relationship: From Human Blood to Social Policy against us
The founding warning that paying for a gift destroys it. Read it with the 2013 meta-analysis (below) that found the blanket version doesn't hold — the truth is narrower and more interesting than the legend.
Incentivizing Blood Donation: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis to Test Titmuss' Hypotheses
The check on the legend: across controlled studies, incentives showed no overall negative effect on donation. We cite our own side's corrections — that's the deal.
The moderator map of the whole paradox: expected, tangible, contingent rewards undermine; praise enhances; surprises don't hurt. The empirical foundation of "honor, not price."
The Haifa daycare study: fine late parents, get more lateness — and the norm never recovers. Famous, vivid, and a 2020 replication attempt failed to reproduce it; we carry both facts.
Incentives and Prosocial Behavior
The mechanism: rewards muddy what a good deed says about the doer. Why paying for virtue can buy less of it — from a Nobel laureate's pen.
What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets
The philosophical statement of the corruption objection: pricing a good can change its meaning. The most readable entry in this section.
Honours versus Money: The Economics of Awards
The economics of the one incentive that crowds motivation in: honors. Includes the failure modes — inflation, envy, error — that our design carries as constraints.
Fostering Public Good Contributions with Symbolic Awards
The randomized trial at Wikipedia: a worthless peer-conferred badge raised volunteer retention ~20%. The cleanest causal evidence that symbolic recognition strengthens giving.
The Nature of Slacktivism against us
Public token gestures reduce later substantive help; one visible good deed can license worse behavior after (d ≈ 0.31, likely inflated by publication bias — the authors say so). The image-economy objection in full — answered as objection 10.
Motivational Spillovers from Awards: Crowding Out in a Multitasking Environment against us
A purely symbolic attendance award that backfired: workers gamed the criterion and the previously punctual got worse. What happens when an honor is built like a price — fixed, announced criteria — and why the Standard has none.
Superstar CEOs against us
Honors corrupting: award-winning CEOs coast, extract pay, manage earnings. What recognition becomes when it's media-conferred celebrity instead of accountable peer regard — the failure our giver-weighting exists to avoid.
Measurement and its pathologies
"Improving ratings": audit in the British University system
Source of the sentence everyone attributes to Goodhart: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." Five pages on what audit culture does to institutions.
Assessing the impact of planned social change
Campbell's law: high-stakes indicators corrupt the processes they monitor. Goodhart's twin, with the social half spelled out.
Coercive Citation in Academic Publishing
One in five surveyed researchers strong-armed into citations. What happened when the world's oldest peer-recognition system was compressed into countable numbers.
The Matthew effect in science funding
Grant winners just above a cutoff accumulate twice the funding of near-identical near-misses. Recognition compounds into aristocracy unless something makes it decay.
Action needed to make carbon offsets from forest conservation work for climate change mitigation
What happens when "verified impact" becomes purchasable: phantom tons at roughly 3× over-crediting, and a 25-year review concluding most programs failed. The case for non-convertibility, in tonnes.
China's Social Credit System in 2021: From fragmentation towards integration
The serious scholarship on what China actually built — no unified score, and chilling anyway. Required reading before invoking the meme in either direction.
Wealth Inequality Is Even Worse in Reputation Economies against us
The inventor of fiction's most famous reputation currency explains why it would be terrible. Our requirements document, written by the opposition.
Working in Public: The Making and Maintenance of Open Source Software
The best field study of a real, working recognition economy — and of its pathologies: stars track popularity while invisible maintainers burn out. Both lessons are ours to keep.
The attention economy
Designing Organizations for an Information-Rich World
"A wealth of information creates a poverty of attention." The Nobel laureate who saw the attention economy coming before the internet existed.
Emotion shapes the diffusion of moralized content in social networks
563,312 tweets: each moral-emotional word raises the share rate ~20%. What a noticeability yardstick selects for, measured.
Engagement, user satisfaction, and the amplification of divisive content on social media
The preregistered audit: engagement ranking amplifies out-group hostility that users say they don't want. Engagement is not preference — it's just what got measured.
The history of the industry that harvests attention, and the best contemporary manual for refusing it. The accessible pair for this whole section.
Design precedents & lineage
なめらかな社会とその敵 (The Smooth Society and Its Enemies)
The closest prior art on Earth: a worked-out currency where purchasing power equals measured contribution, computed like PageRank. We differ at the root — conferred by people, not computed about them, and never a currency at all — and we name the debt.
A Flexible Design for Funding Public Goods
Quadratic funding — the most deployed mechanism for letting how-many-care, not how-much-they-pay, move real money. Its documented sybil attacks taught us personhood-bounding.
Plurality: The Future of Collaborative Technology and Democracy
The broadest contemporary program for plural, community-scale governance of value. Adjacent to us, not identical: their mechanisms allocate money; our measure refuses to become it.
The anthropology of status through giving — and the potlatch warning that giving can escalate into an arms race. Both the precedent and the caution.
Proof that communities govern shared things without central control or privatization, plus eight design principles. The empirical backbone of "plural, community-scale, peer-governed."
The formal result that money's job can be done by a record of who did what for whom — which makes "what does the record forget?" a technical question, not a poetic one.
The proof that GDP-as-sole-yardstick can be dethroned at world scale — and, in Sen's resistance to one-number compression, the warning we build into our plurality rule.
A Short Guide to Gross National Happiness Index
How Bhutan actually computes GNH (nine domains, since 2008). We cite it with its shadows attached — the retrojected origin story, the Lhotshampa expulsion — because a yardstick is not a conscience.
The classic argument that market society inverted the economy–society relationship. Backing value with contribution is, in Polanyi's terms, re-embedding — without breaking the market.
論語と算盤 and 合本主義 (The Analects and the Abacus)
From the man who helped found some five hundred companies: morality and economy are one thing. The Japanese lineage of mission-first capital — philosophy that never got a measurement system, until now.
人新世の「資本論」 (Capital in the Anthropocene)
The 500,000-copy Japanese bestseller arguing growth itself is the crisis. We share his diagnosis of misaimed reward and part ways at the cure — change the measure, keep the market.
Labor, work, action. When machines take labor, what remains is action — the life of deeds among others. Arendt named the post-work question half a century before AI made it urgent.
The floor, work, and the abundant future
Evaluation of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment
The actual evidence on income floors: well-being improves, work doesn't collapse. Also the honest limit — nobody has tested a full livable floor in a rich country.
A frontier-lab CEO forecasting AI abundance and proposing redistribution to match. We cite it as what it is: an interested forecast that makes the yardstick question urgent either way.
Work: A Deep History, from the Stone Age to the Age of Robots
The anthropology of why we work as much as we do — and why endless toil isn't human nature. The careful successor to Sahlins' contested "original affluent society."
Less is More & Doughnut Economics
The adjacent frames: degrowth re-aims the economy's throughput; the doughnut re-aims its goals. Both are macro policy; ours is the question they leave open — what a person is measured by. Compatible, and different.
Every entry above — plus the claims made across this site — is tracked in a public citations audit in the website's repository, with the caveats we are required to carry when we cite it. If you find an error, telling us is an act of impact.
Make impact, not money, the measure of a life.
Read the creed, then add your name.